01. Sex appeal
Melina: Her sexy entrance draws all the eyes, but she refuses to pose for Playboy, as her body "is a temple."
Paris: Starred in a sex tape, has been caught without underwear on several occasions, and never passes on a chance to dress sexy.
The edge goes to Melina. She has more mystery to her, whereas Paris has none, given that the public has seen all of her "bits and pieces".

02. Professions
Melina: She has excelled in her craft, focusing on improving in every aspect from mic work to character to actual ring work. She claims that wrestling is her life, and when she’s not on the road or in the ring, she’s studying it.
Paris: "Famous for being famous", the saying goes. Paris is a socialite, and flirts with different jobs such as modeling, singing, and even frangrance design. Despite all of this, the image she sends out is one of a party girl who lives off her famous family’s name.
The edge goes to Melina. She works hard to improve her talents, whereas it appears that Paris doesn’t work at all.

03. Famous friends
Melina: Her character claims to know all the top celebs, but she has only been seen alongside Kevin Federline, a person the public doesn’t hold in very high esteem.
Paris: Knows practically everyone, and seems to be best friends with all the popular party girls. This socialite has friends in all the right places.
The edge goes to Paris. No one can top this party girl when it comes to knowing everyone who is anyone.

04. Notorious name
Melina: The fans love to hate her, and she has the role of the super bitch down to a science. It’s hard to picture her as anything but a heel.
Paris: Her name elicits groans from many, and she hardly was ever taken seriously in any of her endeavors. After her prison fiasco, everyone knew about Paris Hilton and her bad girl ways.
The edge goes to Paris. She is on the bad girl short list, and everyone with access to a television knows of her less-than-angelic exploits.

05. Versatality
Melina: Has changed her look quite often over the years, and always looks the make her matches unique, busting out innovative moves at every chance.
Paris: Has kept her blonde locks intact for the most part, and aside from hair extension removal has looked the same through it all. A promised image overhaul following her jail stint has likely been forgotten, as she looks and acts like the same Paris Hilton as always.
The edge goes to Melina. She switches it up much more often whereas Paris rests on her laurels, sticking with what’s worked, at least up to her standards.

The Verdict: Melina edges out Paris, 3-2. While Paris may be known worldwide and have countless acquaintances, Melina has shown to be a more versatile person in all aspects, as well as having more sex appeal and being better at her chosen field.

01. Exotic looks
Melina: Melina is of Mexican descent, apparent with her last name "Perez". She has the dark complexion and dark eyes of her heritage, and her eyes, lips, and curvy figure definitely make her stand out amongst the blonde-haired set in the WWE.
Angelina: Has the natural looks that many women pay for, with full lips and bold eyes that aren’t the result of surgical enhancement. Even without makeup, Angelina has the stunning looks that make her stick out in the crowd that is Hollywood, thanks to her mixed ancestry of Czech, French-Canadian, Iroquois and English.
The edge goes to Angelina. Many are astounded that her looks are natural, despite being American by birth. Even among the eye-lifted and lip-plumped set in Hollywood, Angelina stands out.

02. Image overhauls
Melina: She went from the darkly dressed and serious-minded Kyra to a outspoken Diva whose looks could be mistaken for an A-list actress. From Kyra to Melina, she has changed in every possible way.
Angelina: She was a notorious wild child with Elvira-like looks and movie roles as eccentric as her personality. These days, she’s a humanitarian with a spot in the UN and several adopted children who has become a seriously in-demand actress.
The edge goes to Angelina. It is jarring how she has changed in looks and demeanor so drastically, and yet keeps her core values intact.

03. Bad girl image
Melina: She has developed hers soundly over the past few years, growing to be one of the biggest "heat magnets" in the WWE.
Angelina: While once proclaimed as the biggest bad girl in Hollywood, she has become much more tame, settling down with Brad Pitt, starting a family, and becoming a goodwill ambassador.
The edge goes to Melina. She has become much more of a bad girl in progression, while Angelina’s regressed in that department.

04. Aiding the significant other
Melina: Managed Johnny Nitro to 1 OVW Southern Tag Title reign, 3 WWE Tag Title reigns, and 2 Intercontinental Title reigns.
Angelina: Brad Pitt was already a worldwide sensation before he paired up with Angelina, and his career has practically stayed the same, aside from increased attention on his personal life.
The edge goes to Melina. She has helped Johnny Nitro climb to the top of the WWE, where he now battles on without her by his side. Her managerial skills have brought much success to those she’s accompanied.

05. Personal Success
Melina: Has won the Women’s Title once, which she held for 4 months.
Angelina: Won an Oscar and 3 Golden Globes, amongst other awards.
The edge goes to Angelina. She has won awards for several different films. For Melina to equate that, she needs to have a few more Women’s Title reigns.

The Verdict: Angelina beats Melina, 3-2. Melina has brought more success to her partner and keeps cultivating the bad girl image, but Angelina has had more success, had a more drastic image overhaul, and has a more exotic look.

01. Sharp tongues
Melina: She is never short for words, always having something mean-spirited or self indulgent to say. Give Melina a microphone, and she’ll rip apart self esteems and boost her own ego a few notches.
Keira: In interviews, Keira always speaks her mind, whether it be about body image, movie roles, or Hollywood superficiality. She has the face of an angel but the mouth of a sailor, never ceasing to drop a few "f-bombs" to emphasize a point.
The edge goes to Keira. Many are shocked by her blunt manner of speaking, and she has even said that one thing she doesn’t like about Americans is "they don’t cuss enough."

02. Sexy image
Melina: She has a curvy body, one that she shows off in photoshoots, but keeps relatively covered up in the ring. Her ring entrace makes up for that though, because splits are splits, even in tights.
Keira: Her svelte frame brings rumors of anorexia, which have been adamently denied and are nothing but speculation. She regularly claims she has no breasts, just "pecs", but is open about nudity in her films, claiming her body is merely a tool in her craft of acting. She is a sex symbol despite her lack of curves, and shows that the stereotypical "bombshell" image doesn’t apply to everyone.
The edge goes to a tie. Both have their own ways of being sexy, each with a different body type. They show that no matter what you look like, if you have the confidence, you can be sexy.

03. Dating co-workers
Melina: She has paired up with John Morisson on-screen and off. He is a 3-time WWE Tag Team Champion, 2-time Intercontinental Champion, and 1-time ECW Champion.
Keira: She paired up with Rupert Friend, an infatuation for her character in "Pride and Prejudice". He has yet to make a big name for himself, and is currently known mostly for being Keira’s boyfriend.
The edge goes to Melina. Morisson has more of a name by himself, whereas Friend has yet to do so.

04. Trademarks
Melina: Her flexibility is ultilized in and out of her matches, often used to distract opponents to those she’s managing or execute a move that would otherwise be impossible. She makes use of it to bring pain, show off, and maybe even both at the same time.
Keira: Her mouth does the talking, in more ways than one. Keira’s patented pout is her signature look, the only thing constant through her drastic changes in appearance that come with varying roles.
The edge goes to Melina. She is more known for her flexibility than Keira is for her pout. This is understandable, given Melina’s trademark is more blatant and noticable than Keira’s is.

05. Level of demand
Melina: Is one of the WWE’s top Divas, appearing on RAW almost every single week and given priority in storylines and matches.
Keira: Following her starring role in the Pirates of the Caribbean movies, her star has risen and today is one of the most in-demand actresses in the industry. She has become a favorite leading lady.
The edge goes to Keira. Virtually at the top of Hollywood, Keira can take any role she wants. That’s power money can’t buy, and virtually can’t be equated in the wrestling industry.

The Verdict: Melina and Keira tie, 2.5-2.5. Keira is more in-demand in her field, has a sharper tongue, and has an equally-leveled "sexy" image with Melina, who has a co-worker beau who has made more of name for himself and has a more noticable trademark.